Full Bench upholds appeal in industrial agreement registration dispute
The Full Bench has upheld an appeal concerning the proposed registration of the Ovis Community Services Enterprise Agreement 2025. The dispute centred on whether Pat Thomas House Inc (trading as Ovis Community Services) was a constitutional trading corporation and therefore outside the jurisdiction of the Western Australian industrial relations system.
Ovis Community Services is a not-for-profit organisation that provides family and domestic violence services in the Peel region, including crisis accommodation, advocacy services, outreach programs, therapeutic refuge services and transitional housing. Most of its funding is received through grants and service agreements with the Department of Communities.
At first instance, the Commission determined that Ovis was a trading corporation because it received government funding under service agreements for the delivery of services. As a result, the Commission concluded that it lacked jurisdiction to register the proposed industrial agreement. Both Ovis and the union appealed that finding, contending that the organisation’s activities should not be characterised as trading activities.
The Full Bench undertook an extensive examination of the organisation’s funding arrangements, constitutional objects and service delivery model. A central issue was whether the organisation's agreements with the State involved the commercial sale of services or the delivery of government-funded community welfare programs. The Full Bench distinguished earlier authorities involving fee-for-service and competitive market arrangements, finding that Ovis largely operated as a provider of public welfare services funded by fixed government grants designed to achieve social policy objectives.
The Full Bench also considered that accommodation contributions paid by refuge residents were nominal, not commercially set, and were intended to assist clients transition back into independent living. Interest income and other receipts were likewise found insufficient to characterise the organisation as engaging in substantial trading activities.
The Full Bench concluded that Ovis was not a trading corporation. The appeal was upheld, the earlier decision was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the Commission for further consideration of the proposed industrial agreement registration.