Prison kitchen supervisor’s unfair dismissal claim dismissed

The Commission has dismissed an unfair dismissal application brought by a probationary Vocational Support Officer (Chef Supervisor) employed at Greenough Regional Prison. The employee's role involved supervising prison kitchen operations and prisoners assigned to work in the prison kitchen.

The employee’s appointment was subject to a nine-month probationary period. The Department of Justice discharged him from probation after forming the view that he was not suitable for ongoing employment due to concerns about his performance, including food quality and quantity, food ordering, kitchen hygiene, stock management, audit compliance and supervision of kitchen operations.

The employee argued that he had not been given a fair opportunity to improve and that proper performance management procedures had not been followed. He contended that many of the issues identified were outside his control, were caused by broader workplace problems, or related to the performance of other staff members.

The Commission considered evidence of numerous meetings, audits, inspections, complaints and performance discussions conducted throughout the probationary period. The Department relied on repeated counselling, written performance concerns, Regular Monitoring Forms and a formal notice proposing discharge. The evidence showed that concerns relating to food service standards, cleanliness, ordering practices and management of the prison kitchen had been raised with the employee on multiple occasions between May and September 2024.

Commissioner Walkington found that the Department’s concerns were genuinely held and had been clearly communicated to the employee. The Commissioner also found that the employee was given opportunities to respond and improve but that the expected improvements were not achieved. Applying established principles concerning probationary employment, the Commission concluded that the Department had not misused or abused its right to discharge a probationary employee.

The application was dismissed.

The decision can be read here.