Probationary officer's unfair dismissal application refused
The Commission has refused to grant a probationary Youth Custodial Officer an extension of time to file an unfair dismissal application after hearing the unfair dismissal claim on its merits.
Youth Custodial Officers supervise and care for young people detained within the State's youth justice system. The applicant's employment was terminated during the probationary period following concerns arising from interactions with a detainee observed on CCTV footage, on the grounds the employer had assessed him as being unsuitable.
The applicant described the incidents that were observed on CCTV as playful banter intended to build rapport and reduce conflict with the detainee. He accepted that the interactions were contrary to aspects of Youth Custodial Officer training, including a ‘Grooming Behaviours’ document. He accepted that footage did not ‘look good’. However, he said that his conduct was well intentioned, and that it was impractical to adhere to what was taught in the training.
The Department contended that the interactions were inconsistent with required professional boundaries and raised concerns about the applicant's suitability for employment in a custodial environment.
Commissioner Walkington considered evidence from the applicant and two other witnesses regarding Youth Custodial Officer training, the standards applicable to Youth Custodial Officers and the significance of maintaining professional boundaries with detainees. Having heard from the applicant, the Commissioner noted he believed his own approach to detainee management was preferable to the methods taught and required by the Department.
The test for unfair dismissal in the context of probationary employment differs to that which applies outside of a probationary period. The Commissioner found the Department's concerns regarding the applicant’s suitability were found to be genuine and reasonably held. This meant that the unfair dismissal claim could not succeed. Accordingly, an extension of time was not warranted.