Warren De Prazer -v- Western Australian Railway Officers' Union
Document Type: Order
Matter Number: PRES 3/2010
Matter Description: Application for Orders determining validity of resolutions passed at conference and council meetings
Industry: Unions
Jurisdiction: President
Member/Magistrate name: The Honourable J H Smith, Acting President
Delivery Date: 29 Jun 2010
Result: Declaration and Order made
Citation: 2010 WAIRC 00388
WAIG Reference: 90 WAIG 614
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION
PARTIES WARREN DE PRAZER
APPLICANT
-AND-
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN RAILWAY OFFICERS' UNION
RESPONDENT
CORAM THE HONOURABLE J H SMITH, ACTING PRESIDENT
DATE TUESDAY, 29 JUNE 2010
FILE NO/S PRES 3 OF 2010
CITATION NO. 2010 WAIRC 00388
Result Declaration and Order made
Appearances
APPLICANT MR D H SCHAPPER (OF COUNSEL)
RESPONDENT MS P BYRNE (AS AGENT)
Declaration and Order
This matter having come on for hearing before me on 18 June 2010, and having heard Mr Schapper of counsel on behalf of the applicant, and Ms Byrne as agent on behalf of the respondent, and reasons for decision having been delivered on 25 June 2010, the Acting President, pursuant to the powers conferred under the Industrial Relations Act 1979, hereby —
1. DECLARES the true interpretation of —
(a) rule 8(b) of the rules of the Union is that while the 14 Branches defined in r 33 of the rules of the Union remain unclosed by Council, to constitute a quorum of a meeting of Delegate Conference, representatives of 11 Branches must attend and participate in a meeting of Delegate Conference; and
(b) rule 12(o) of the rules of the Union is that to constitute a quorum of a meeting of Council, exclusive of the members of the Executive, five ordinary members of Council or four ordinary members of Council and the Union member on the Railways Classification Board must attend and participate in a meeting of Council.
2. ORDERS that —
(a) the observance of r 8(b) of the rules of the Union and r 12(o) of the rules of the Union is waived;
(b) that the attendance and participation of the members of the Executive and the Council Delegate constitute a quorum of Council and as constituted is deemed to have the authority to exercise all of the powers and functions of Council (except as varied and modified by this order) pursuant to the rules of the Union;
(c) the meeting held on 31 March 2010 attended by the members of the Executive and the Council Delegate is deemed to be a valid meeting of Council and the resolutions passed at that meeting are deemed to be valid;
(d) that the attendance and participation of the members of the Executive and the Conference Delegate constitute a quorum of Delegate Conference at which all are entitled to vote and as constituted is deemed to have the authority to exercise all the powers and functions of Delegate Conference (except as varied and modified by this order) pursuant to the rules of the Union; and
(e) the meeting held on 31 March 2010 attended by the members of the Executive and the Conference Delegate is deemed to be a valid meeting of Delegate Conference and the resolutions passed at that meeting are deemed to be valid.
ACTING PRESIDENT
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION
PARTIES Warren De Prazer
APPLICANT
-and-
Western Australian Railway Officers' Union
RESPONDENT
CORAM The Honourable J H Smith, Acting President
DATE TUESday, 29 June 2010
FILE NO/S PRES 3 OF 2010
CITATION NO. 2010 WAIRC 00388
Result Declaration and Order made
Appearances
Applicant Mr D H Schapper (of counsel)
Respondent Ms P Byrne (as agent)
Declaration and Order
This matter having come on for hearing before me on 18 June 2010, and having heard Mr Schapper of counsel on behalf of the applicant, and Ms Byrne as agent on behalf of the respondent, and reasons for decision having been delivered on 25 June 2010, the Acting President, pursuant to the powers conferred under the Industrial Relations Act 1979, hereby —
1. DECLARES the true interpretation of —
(a) rule 8(b) of the rules of the Union is that while the 14 Branches defined in r 33 of the rules of the Union remain unclosed by Council, to constitute a quorum of a meeting of Delegate Conference, representatives of 11 Branches must attend and participate in a meeting of Delegate Conference; and
(b) rule 12(o) of the rules of the Union is that to constitute a quorum of a meeting of Council, exclusive of the members of the Executive, five ordinary members of Council or four ordinary members of Council and the Union member on the Railways Classification Board must attend and participate in a meeting of Council.
2. ORDERS that —
(a) the observance of r 8(b) of the rules of the Union and r 12(o) of the rules of the Union is waived;
(b) that the attendance and participation of the members of the Executive and the Council Delegate constitute a quorum of Council and as constituted is deemed to have the authority to exercise all of the powers and functions of Council (except as varied and modified by this order) pursuant to the rules of the Union;
(c) the meeting held on 31 March 2010 attended by the members of the Executive and the Council Delegate is deemed to be a valid meeting of Council and the resolutions passed at that meeting are deemed to be valid;
(d) that the attendance and participation of the members of the Executive and the Conference Delegate constitute a quorum of Delegate Conference at which all are entitled to vote and as constituted is deemed to have the authority to exercise all the powers and functions of Delegate Conference (except as varied and modified by this order) pursuant to the rules of the Union; and
(e) the meeting held on 31 March 2010 attended by the members of the Executive and the Conference Delegate is deemed to be a valid meeting of Delegate Conference and the resolutions passed at that meeting are deemed to be valid.
ACTING PRESIDENT